On Tuesday, the Michigan Supreme Court vacated life without parole sentences for a number of people convicted of felony murder prior to 1980.

The ruling has reignited debates over public safety and the constitutional rights of convicted criminals.

The court’s decision to vacate the convictions was based on a 1980 ruling that required prosecutors to prove someone had malicious intent to secure a felony murder conviction.

The court’s Tuesday ruling retroactively applied the ruling to people convicted prior to 1980, a decision that will lighten sentences for numerous criminals convicted of violent crimes.

The Michigan Attorney General’s office argued that retroactively applying the ruling will allow some individuals who committed crimes of “breathtaking brutality” to get lighter sentences.

“There are some cases of just breathtaking brutality,” Eric Restuccia of the Michigan Attorney General’s office said. “And the idea that those offenders have an unconstitutional sentence is just — it’s an untenable conclusion.”

Attorney Mira Edmonds, arguing for an individual convicted of felony murder prior to 1980, told Michigan Public that while Tuesday’s ruling “is fairly narrow and affects a fairly small number of individuals, it does indicate a willingness to re-examine past injustices in sentencing and try to rectify those.”

The Michigan Supreme Court has vacated the convictions of dozens of murderers in recent years, including a 2025 ruling that made mandatory life sentences for 19- and 20-year-olds unconstitutional.

The Michigan Supreme Court is currently composed of a 6-1 Democratic nominated majority, with the sole Republican Justice’s term set to expire in 2031.

[RELATED: Court Tosses More Whitmer Kidnapping Plot Convictions in Another Blow to Nessel]

[RELATED: El-Sayed Embellishes Family’s Michigan Roots]